Having great home insurance protection requires focusing on value not just price

Whether you’re buying a new home or have owned your home for some time, understanding what components make up a solid insurance protection plan for your home, your valuables, and your liability is essential.

While your home may not change much over the years, insurance isn’t “a set it and forget it” decision. Changes in your life, home improvements, and construction in the general marketplace can change your insurance needs.

If you’re house hunting, start thinking about insurance coverage early on. Discuss options with an insurance professional to help you consider coverage issues that may impact your home-buying decision. Suppose you own a home and haven’t considered your options in years. In that case, you might be surprised to know that insurance options are constantly changing. So, it’s wise to review everything periodically and consider alternatives if you’re concerned you’re not getting a good value.

Here are some issues to consider:

Buying a New Home?

Location, size, construction type, and condition affect the cost and availability of homeowner insurance.  Age of home, condition of the roof, construction up to current code, risk of flooding, and presence of a swimming pool impact insurance costs. Homes near the coast generally cost more to insure than inland homes and typically have a higher windstorm/hurricane deductible. The quality and location of the fire department in the city/town and the availability of fire hydrants are also insurance rating factors. Ask the current owner for a copy of the insurance loss history report on the home, such as a Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange (C.L.U.E.) report, which they can obtain from their insurance company. This will let you know if there have been any past claims so that you can inquire if it was repaired correctly.

What Would it Cost to Rebuild Your Home?

Remember that it typically costs more to rebuild a home than the current real estate market price. For insurance purposes, you want to be adequately insured for replacement costs to ensure you’ll have the funds to rebuild. Companies generally adjust this amount using formulas based on construction costs, but it’s wise to periodically complete a home replacement cost estimator to ensure that you aren’t over- or under-insured. Because replacement costs are estimates, we strongly recommend purchasing an extended or guaranteed replacement cost endorsement that provides additional coverage if repair costs exceed the dwelling coverage limit due to unforeseen circumstances.

What Would it Cost to Replace All of Your Possessions?

The value of furniture, clothing, appliances, electronics, and all other contents depreciates over time. Basic policies only provide “actual cash value,” which factors in a reduction for depreciation; we strongly recommend having “replacement cost” on the contents so that you would receive funds to replace possessions at today’s cost of purchase.  Creating one is essential if you don’t have a home inventory  of all your possessions.  Your possessions might be worth more than you anticipate, requiring additional coverage.

Do You Have High-Value Jewelry, Art, Antiques, Furs, Firearms, or Collections?

Some personal possessions such as jewelry, furs, firearms, and silverware have specific theft limits on a homeowners policy so that you may want special insurance protection in the event of a theft. Also, high-valued jewelry, art, antiques, or other collectibles could account for a large percentage of the personal property limit on your home insurance policy.  In such situations, you may want to consider having special coverage for such items by “scheduling” them separately under your home policy. This provides coverage for them in expanded situations and covers them separately outside the general personal property limit so that you will have protection for all your possessions.

Building Code Coverage

Building codes change over time. If your home is damaged, the cost to rebuild/repair may also involve costs to bring your home up to current building codes. Home policies typically have a limited amount of this type of protection called “ordinance or law” coverage. This amount may not be sufficient depending on the age of your home and potential changes to building codes. This option is worth investing in so that you don’t have a shortfall in a major claim.

Choose the Highest Deductible You Can Afford

Raising the deductible increases the amount you’ll pay out of pocket if you have a claim, but a higher deductible will lower your premium, which, over time, can provide savings. Home insurance should be considered catastrophe insurance to be used in the event of a significant loss.  A series of small claims can result in losing out on loss-free discounts, premium increases, and potentially your home policy being nonrenewed by the carrier. Be sure you have the deductible available in your savings in case of a claim.

Discount Opportunities

Some insurance companies provided discounts in some qualified situations, including:

  • Home and auto insurance combined multi-policy with same company discount
  • New Construction
  • Central station fire & burglar alarms
  • Smoke detectors & sprinkler systems
  • Deadbolt locks
  • Major home revitalization/renovations
  • Credits for having a loss-free record
  • Loyalty discounts
  • Upgrades to plumbing, heating & electrical
  • Wind resistant shutters

Optional Coverages that Can Be Worth Spending a Little More

  • Earthquake insurance  – A standard policy does not cover earthquake damage; while New England isn’t a high-risk area, it does have a history of quakes.
  • Home business – if you operate a business out of your home, business equipment and liability are excluded from home policies unless you specifically purchase coverage with a permitted incidental occupancies endorsement.
  • Heating oil leak remediation
  • Limited fungi, wet or dry rot, or bacteria coverage increase
  • Flood Insurance
  • Personal article floater for high-value items
  • Service line coverage
  • Home equipment system breakdown
  • Water backup and sump discharge or overflow coverage – excluded from a standard policy, you can purchase some limited coverage in the event of such a situation
  • For rental properties:
    • Increased rental income protection
    • Coverage for furnishings/contents
    • Lead poisoning coverage (homes built before 1978)

Is Your Home in a Flood Plain?

If you have a mortgage, your lender will generally require that you purchase flood insurance if your home is in a high-risk flood zone. However, flooding can occur in lower-risk zones, and a home policy does not cover floods. Visit www.floodsmart.gov or call to speak with an insurance professional about flood insurance. The premiums for flood insurance in lower-risk zones are less than you might assume, so it’s an option worth considering.

Provide Correct Information for ALL Application Questions

Providing inaccurate information can result in an inaccurate quote that could leave you underinsured. Be sure to identify any upgrades to your property. Also, incorrect information provided at the time of application could result in policy cancellation or denial of coverage in a claim situation, which is why answering questions accurately is essential.

Personal Umbrella Liability Protection.

Lawsuits can result in huge settlements if you or a family member are found responsible for injuring someone or damaging their property.  If you have a pool, a dog, a trampoline, or anything else that may create additional exposure, look for options to expand your liability coverage.  A personal umbrella liability policy can provide an extra $1 million+ layer of coverage over and above your home (and auto) policy limits.

At Murphy Insurance Agency, our knowledgeable professionals can help you compare options among eight (8) different insurance carriers and guide you in making wise decisions about homeowner, condominium unit owner, and renters insurance. Ultimately, you must decide the level and types of risks you want to insure against based on your needs and budget. Remember that it’s often worth spending a little more to have expanded coverage rather than risk a situation where your policy would not respond with financial support. Please Contact Us today to discuss your insurance needs

Saving money is essential, but being covered is even more important. 

Ready to compare options? Click for a quote.

Read Other Blog Posts

Murphy Insurance Proudly Sponsors the Groton Road Race

Murphy Insurance Proudly Sponsors the Groton Road Race

Murphy Insurance Agency is proud to sponsor the 2026 Groton Road Race on May 3. With 5K, 10K, and Fun Run options, this beloved local event brings runners and families together to celebrate community, health, and one of Groton’s best traditions.
Plumbing & Water Damage | Homeowner's Manual Blog Series

Plumbing & Water Damage Prevention | Homeowner’s Manual Blog Series

Water damage is one of the most common and costly issues homeowners face, but many problems are preventable. From fixing leaks to maintaining sump pumps, simple steps can protect your home. Explore practical tips from Murphy Insurance’s Homeowner’s Manual to stay ahead.
Why Flood Insurance Matters

Why Flood Insurance Matters

Flooding can cause costly damage to homes and create health risks from mold, even outside high-risk zones. Because standard homeowners insurance excludes flood damage and losses are rising, flood insurance is a critical layer of protection for homeowners.
Massachusetts Boaters A New Safety Requirement You Need to Know Before Summer

Massachusetts Boaters: A New Safety Requirement You Need to Know Before Summer

Massachusetts boaters should be aware of a new safety law taking effect in 2026. Many operators will now need a boating safety certificate based on age. Learn who is affected, key deadlines, and how to complete an approved course before the season begins.
Why Umbrella Insurance Matters for Local Families in Bolton, MA

Why Umbrella Insurance Matters for Local Families in Bolton, MA

Umbrella insurance provides added liability protection beyond your home and auto policies—essential for Bolton, MA, families with high-value homes, teenage drivers, or those involved in recreational activities. Learn how Murphy Insurance can help you safeguard your future with affordable coverage tailored to your lifestyle.
Driver with phone

Preventing Distracted Driving

According to the National Safety Council, more than 3,000 people die each year as a result of distracted driving crashes. Keep reading to learn what you can do to reduce potential distractions while you drive—keeping both yourself and others safe on the road.

Financial Literacy Month: Building Confidence in Your Financial Future

April is Financial Literacy Month, a time to strengthen your understanding of budgeting, saving, and planning. From managing daily expenses to protecting your assets with the right insurance, financial knowledge helps you make smarter decisions and build a more secure future.
500 Blog Posts

500 Blog Posts and Counting: A Milestone Worth Celebrating

We are celebrating our 500th blog post, marking years of consistently helping clients, partners, and communities navigate the complexity of insurance, reduce risk, and make more informed decisions through clear, practical, and easy-to-understand guidance they can rely on every day.
Roof & Gutter Care Homeowners Manual

Roof & Gutter Care | Homeowner’s Manual Blog Series

Your roof and gutters are your home’s first line of defense against the elements. Learn how simple maintenance steps can prevent costly repairs, reduce water damage risk, and help avoid insurance claim issues. Stay ahead with practical tips every homeowner should follow.

Visit Our Homeowners Insurance Page

Homeowners Insurance

At Murphy Insurance, we take great care in assessing your options for homeowners insurance to ensure that you receive the most favorable value. Our dedication to serving you entails collaborating with highly-rated insurance providers and conducting comprehensive assessments of available choices. Our goal is to achieve the ideal equilibrium between affordability and coverage that suits your unique needs. Please let us provide you with a customized homeowners insurance quote.